Tangling With A Snake

old keys to who knows what“Why do you back down?  If you know you are right, why don’t you prove your point?”

I reached for a cup of Earl Grey.  “I don’t like confrontation.”

“It’s not necessarily confrontation, though.  Sometimes it’s just discourse.  Two people disagree, they talk it out, and they come to an understanding.  It’s not a big deal.”

I looked at Jen and she was shaking her head.  “What do you think, Jen?”  She shrugged her shoulders and refused to comment.

 

“But Will, is it enough to be right without having to convince the other person?  Why is it necessary to convince them of your perspective?  Is it a guy thing?”

“I’m not gonna be a doormat.  If I know I’m right, I’m not gonna back down.”

“Even if it’s someone important in your life?  What if proving you are right costs you that relationship?  What if you alienate others because you always insist on being right?  Is that a good choice?”

 

Will stood up from his seat.  He’s gotten a lot taller since we first started having these in-depth conversations.  He’s not my little boy any more.  He said, “I think you can get your point across without being an ass.”

“Great.  But what if you have to keep having the same conversation?  What if the conversation keeps coming around to…  say … politics, and the other person gets caustic and agitated in an effort to get you to see their point?  You know they aren’t going to change your mind, so it’s futile.  Why continue to argue about it if it always ends up the same?  Why not just agree to disagree?  I don’t see how it’s worth the energy to keep having the same argument.”

 

 

 

“But mom, you don’t like confrontation, and I don’t mind, if I’m getting my point across.”

“Even when the other person gets nasty?”

“That doesn’t bother me.”

“And that’s where we are totally different.  It’s not that I don’t stand firm in my beliefs.  When discussions get heated, I shut down.  I prefer harmony.  I don’t see the need to prove that I’m right.  Kudos to you for being strong in your position and your voice.”

“But don’t you owe it to the people close to you to make sure they know where you stand?”

“Well, if someone is close to me, they already know my position.  If they keep challenging me on something, then we have bigger issues.”

Will shook his head the way teenagers do when they have no clue where an adult – especially their parent – is coming from.

 

“You know, Will, maybe I just don’t need to prove myself anymore.  And I sure don’t enjoy an argument for the sake of arguing.  You’re establishing your place in the world.  You’re making choices and figuring out who you are, and making your opinions known is all part of that.

I stood up from my stool.  “But I stand firm on this:  relationships – the close ones – are more important than being right.  It does you no good to be right when doing so means you end up all alone.  If someone keeps coming at you wanting to tangle, it’s up to you to decide:  Do I want to be right; or do I want this person in my life.  Ultimately, you also may want to decide how much you value this relationship, if they always want to argue with you.”

 

I turned to Jen who hasn’t said a word through this whole debate.  “Jen, what are you thinking?”

Without hesitating, Jen said, “Do you walk around the rattlesnake, or do you walk up to it and tell it why it shouldn’t bite you?”

 

 

 

Related Post

The Impact of Attitude The longer I live, the more I realize the impact of attitude on life. Attitude, to me, is more important than facts. It is more important than the past, than education, than money, than circumstances, than failures, than successes, than what other pe...
Narcissist for a Day Today I'm going to be a narcissist.  I'm going to put myself first.   I need to get something done - for me.  In order to do that, I need to put all your stuff aside. You know I love you.  Right?  And all day long, while I'm making myself a p...
Mom, Why Would Somebody Hack Your Site? "You guys, the site was hacked." "What do ya mean?" "Somebody found a way to get into the site and change the coding." "How do ya know?" "Aunt Pat called.  She said she tried to open a post through Google Reader and the link to the post s...
Steering Clear "Do I have to?" "Honey, two runs a couple times a ski season, and that's it.  It won't kill ya, and it's way better than a whole ski day with him." She buckles her boots and sighs, "I know." "I'll be waiting for you at the bottom of the lift."  I ...

Tags: , , , , ,

4 comments

  1. I love that zinger at the end!

    It’s a complicated thing though, isn’t it? Figuring out when to stand up and when to smile and nod.

    I have a friend whose friendship I value deeply, but we have very divergent views on religion. I’ve accepted that neither of us is going to convince the other, and that it’s much better to just steer clear of the subject.

    When it comes to dealing with my ex, I’m a lot less interested in proving I’m right (although it sure would be good — just once — to hear it!). The important thing is ensuring my child is OK.

    I was given valuable feedback once by a former boss, who said that if you feel passionately that the other person is wrong, you need to give them a path under which they could change their mind and still save face. Otherwise they will become so invested in proving their point that you will never get the result you want.

    Self righteousness can be a very powerful galvanizing force. It can propel one to stand up and fight for what’s right, regardless of the personal consequences. Use it judiciously, and it’s a force for positive powerful change. Use it indiscriminately, and you end up angry and alone.

  2. If I know my “opponent” is a rattlesnake, I’d carefully walk around any day, or back off. At Will’s age he’d probably want to take that sucker on! If he does it enough times, with consistent success, he might – just might – turn into a seriously world class rattlesnake tangler. And if he gets bit and survives it, he might become a very wise person who shares his wisdom about how to avoid rattlesnakes.

  3. M,

    Yes, it is ridiculously complicated deciding when to stand up. I often wonder if I’d managed to do that earlier in my marriage to the ex, how different would things be now. Of course, I probably wouldn’t have Will and Jen, because I’m convinced the N wouldn’t have stuck around long enough to have kids if I hadn’t been so accommodating. But that’s hindsight.

    Thanks so much for your input. I’m going to have Will read your comment, especially the last paragraph.

  4. Pat,

    Hellooooo…. :)

    Ah… teenage boys. Luckily I had a brother. The similarities between my brother and Will are astounding. I find myself looking at Will and thinking, okay, I sort of remember this behavior. I just hope he doesn’t get bit by snakes too may times.

Leave a comment